Alberta Under Smith
Oct. 13th, 2023 06:58 pmThe United Conservative Party released their Policy and Governance Resolutions for the upcoming legislature. It's pretty much a shit show from start to finish.
Governance Resolutions (1-19)are mostly minor changes to how government operates. Stuff like who's eligible for constituency associations, whether you can use a physical membership card, etc. The biggest thing is that #17 which says there must be a leadership review if the party leader loses an election/by-election.
I imagine these things could be manipulated to give subtle biases to rural or right-leaning ridings, but honestly my eyes glazed over. It's a case of me knowing that they're all bad actors, and assuming the worst.
And speaking of the worst, the policy proposals are where the real evil meat is. They fall into several broad categories.
Also, they describe the Convoy protests as the "2022 truck parking problem", and boy howdy, are they still angry that Ottawa invoked extreme measures to put a stop to it.
“Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition …There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.” - Frank Wilhoit.
And remember, this won't be used to keep you from being fired for voting New Democrat. But if you try to keep convoy protesters out of your store, watch out!
Mostly this is an anti-trans bill, but it's fractally bad since it also means under-age kids can't seek treatment for other things ranging from embarrassing to traumatic without exposing themselves to their parents. No birth control for you little Susie, and god help you if you need an abortion, or even something as simple as a vaccination.
Also, there's been no serious proposals to eliminate physical currency. Even if we were to do it, it's the sort of thing Canada wouldn't do first. We'd wait until a few European countries did it first. Which they're not.
Note the opposition to “future legalization of MAiD... for minor children”. Like, is anyone seriously floating this? Or are they just pulling a “think of the children”? Anyway, Cons don't like assisted suicide.
Wait! If they're successful at this, and then they subsequently get fetuses declared “people”, they've just done an end-run around legal abortions.
This one is worse than I thought!
Governance Resolutions (1-19)are mostly minor changes to how government operates. Stuff like who's eligible for constituency associations, whether you can use a physical membership card, etc. The biggest thing is that #17 which says there must be a leadership review if the party leader loses an election/by-election.
I imagine these things could be manipulated to give subtle biases to rural or right-leaning ridings, but honestly my eyes glazed over. It's a case of me knowing that they're all bad actors, and assuming the worst.
And speaking of the worst, the policy proposals are where the real evil meat is. They fall into several broad categories.
Damn You Ottawa
No one ever lost votes blaming Ottawa for their problems.#1 Defend Alberta’s economy and autonomy by opposing all attempts by the Federal government to impose net zero by 2035.Straight up obstructing the federal government. You can tell what their main priorities are since this was #1 on the list. We might want to screw the gay kids, and support wing-nuts, but we will always, absolutely, support our Oil and Gas Overlords first and foremost.
#15 Recognize that Albertans have many endangered God-given rights and freedoms that are not formally affirmed in The Canadian Constitution, its enactments or Charter of Rights and Freedoms.This goes into more detail, but boils down to wanting US-style bill or rights (especially the “rights” of the really wacky states, and guns guns guns). Also note the inclusion of “God-given”. This came from our Premier's riding, and I just wish she'd move to rural Idaho already, since she likes it so much.
Also, they describe the Convoy protests as the "2022 truck parking problem", and boy howdy, are they still angry that Ottawa invoked extreme measures to put a stop to it.
Let Assholes be Assholes
These are all about letting the wing-nut freak flag fly without facing any consequences. Note that it won't protect you.“Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition …There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.” - Frank Wilhoit.
#2 Protect an individual’s right to free expression.It goes on to point out that people are criticized for having opinions, and sometimes even fired for them. Basically, the UCP wants to make it illegal to suffer the consequences of your actions. This will become a theme as we go into different categories.
And remember, this won't be used to keep you from being fired for voting New Democrat. But if you try to keep convoy protesters out of your store, watch out!
#25 make the Alberta Human Rights Tribunal and all other administrative and regulatory body hearings subject to the same rules of evidence and burden of proof as followed by the courts.Organizations can no longer have ethical obligations for their members, only legal ones. And because these organizations typically don't have the apparatus for investigating or prosecuting crime the way the justice system has, this effectively means no sanctions without a pre-existing conviction, or more effort than their willing to spend.
#28 Require all regulatory professional associations and trade organizations to limit investigations of their members for complaints regarding professional conduct of their members to instances of activities that occur while ‘on the job,’ and limit the application of any Code of Conduct to professional activities and exclude personal affairs.You can be a tiki-torch wielding convoy participant wearing actual swastikas, but I can't fire you, provided you only do it on your day off.
COVID Bullshit
They rode in on a wave of wing-nut anti-vaxx/anti-mask bullshit, so you knew there was going to be a lot of this. Because even the tiny impositions we had to put up with compared to other countries was an affront to their right to hang out at Tim's and breath on the cashier.#3: Protect a medical practitioner’s right to research, speak, and write; and protect Medical Doctors and all healthcare professionals from having their licenses to practice threatened for publicly expressing professional medical opinions in any public setting.The goal here it to eliminate consequences for healthcare professionals who spout nonsense.
#4 Protect an individual’s right to informed consent decisions regarding their own body.The goal here is to eliminate consequences for patients who accept nonsense. Also, patients already have consent. I think this is here to force doctors to put up with patient nonsense. i.e. it's less about refusing treatment, it's about not allowing the Doctor to contradict the patient who wants woo treatment.
#7 Protect an individual’s right to privacy and confidentiality of their health care information.No vaccination status cards ever again. Because the rational people aren't allowed to protect themselves from the irrational people.
#16 Enshrine the doctor-patient relationship by:Hamstring the Alberta Medical Association, specifically so they can't sanction doctors who prescribe ivermectin.protecting Alberta physicians from undue third-party interference, to neither compel physicians to prescribe treatments nor prohibit them from prescribing treatments, and to include the right of physicians to prescribe off-label medications using their best discretion with the informed consent of the patient.
Anti-Trans bills
Of course they're anti-trans. Were you not paying attention? They'll go after the merely LGBQ folks next you know. And after that, people who don't perform Ozzie-and-Harriet gender roles close enough. Alternative sexuality terrifies these people.#8 Require Teachers, Schools, and School Boards to obtain the written consent of the parent/guardian of a student under the age of 16 prior to changing the name and/or pronouns used by the student.If you're dad is going to beat the shit out of you for being queer, the school isn't going to give you a safe space. Better stay in the closet. Also, they get to dead-name you.
#17 Support a comprehensive Bill of Parental Rights which ensures that all legislation will recognize and support parents’ rights to be informed of and in-charge of all decisions to do with all services paid for by the province, including education and health care.I feel it's always worth asking, a parent's right to what? And the answer is to treat their children like property they can control, instead of human beings they have obligations to.
Mostly this is an anti-trans bill, but it's fractally bad since it also means under-age kids can't seek treatment for other things ranging from embarrassing to traumatic without exposing themselves to their parents. No birth control for you little Susie, and god help you if you need an abortion, or even something as simple as a vaccination.
#29 Protect inmates who were female at conception and are housed at correctional and remand centers for women operated by Alberta Correctional Services by refusing to house any inmate who was male at conception at said correctional and remand centers.We're going to protect women, by making sure that some of them get the shit kicked out of them in the men's prisons.
Anti-Education
The more you're educated, the less likely you are to vote conservative.#6 Ban post-secondary institutions from the use of race as a factor in any admissions program or procedure.They want to eliminate affirmative action. Can't be a white supremacist if you don't keep the non-white's below you.
#9 Ensure post-Secondary institutions shall be places of free thought and learning of employable skills by eliminating all Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) offices at all public universities, colleges, technical institutes, and trades schools and all adult education institutions. They are not places for indoctrination of identity politics, reverse racism, or radicalization. Any postsecondary institution that maintains a DEI office, policy, or equivalent shall lose government financial support.They want to eliminate any accommodation for anyone not a white, het, cis, able-bodied male. And they'll starve post-secondary to do it. Also notice the language of “indoctrination”. You're free to be an anti-masking lunatic who screams at the cashier, but not to provide a hand up to a discriminated minority. Freedom indeed.
#19 Implement a school voucher system to ensure that education funding follows each student and enhances the vision of school choice.We already have a voucher system. This makes it more explicit, and insures they get more funding (presumably at the expense of the public system).
#20 Ensure that teachers, schools, school boards, and third parties providing services to kindergarten to Grade 12 schools do not provide access to materials of a sexual, racist, or abusive nature, including, but not limited to, books, handouts, online materials, and live events that are not part of the Alberta Program of Studies.No telling the kids you're gay. And certainly don't suggest books to kids trying to figure out why they're different from the others. Best to stay in the closet and implicitly tell them they should stay in the closet too.
Typical Conservative Bugaboos
Their hit parade. This is a catch-all for shit conservatives hate.#5 Protect Albertans’ right to have access to goods and services using cash and the option to bank with provincially regulated institutions that supply cash instead of Digital Currency.This is a combination of typical Conservative opposition to technology, fear of (((global elites))), and being pissy that some stores didn't accept cash during the lock-down.
Also, there's been no serious proposals to eliminate physical currency. Even if we were to do it, it's the sort of thing Canada wouldn't do first. We'd wait until a few European countries did it first. Which they're not.
#10 Oppose the federal expansion of Medical Assistance in Dying (“MAiD”) qualifying criteria to include those suffering solely from mental illness and oppose the future legalization of MAiD as a care option for minor children.Because if you want to die, you must therefore be mentally ill.
Note the opposition to “future legalization of MAiD... for minor children”. Like, is anyone seriously floating this? Or are they just pulling a “think of the children”? Anyway, Cons don't like assisted suicide.
Wait! If they're successful at this, and then they subsequently get fetuses declared “people”, they've just done an end-run around legal abortions.
This one is worse than I thought!
#12 Prohibit any land use or development planning initiatives that would restrict movement of residents as per Section 6 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and FreedomsThey go on to say that this is explicitly anti-15 minute cites legislation, based off of the usual misunderstanding of Oxford's taxation proposal. Also, a prime example of Cleek's Law.
#21 Not support the establishment of solar farms in the areas of the agricultural Canada Land Inventory (CLI) Class 1, 2, or 3 soils.Well, it's not a ban, just a “not support”. Probably because telling farmer's “no” outright might cost them votes. But they're sure not going to support renewables, because of our Oil & Gas Overlords.
#22 End provincial funding for supervised consumption sites.Of course. Those junkies should just die or move to Vancouver.
Miscellaneous, Possibly Not So Evil Proposals
I can't really judge these, but I'll list and comment anyway.#11 support programs, eliminate red tape, and reduce taxes for the succession of the family farm to the next generation of farmers in our primary agricultural sector.I guess.
#13 Prevent concerns about electoral fraud in Albertan elections by (at a minimum) banning, except by plebiscite, all use of any and all electronic machine for tabulation or counting of ballots for any provincial election.I do like paper ballots. And wasn't happy with the last bullshit senator-in-waiting election being part of a scantron with other measures. It mean't I couldn't effectively refuse the ballot.
#14 Support the establishment of a Digital Bill of Rights that outlines the following rights.They list the rights, and I don't really have a problem with them.
#18 Encourage increased nitrogen production in our petrochemical sector to reduce costs and improve the availability of fertilizer for Alberta farmers.Note they say encourage, not require. It's a motion to ask our Oil & Gas Overlords nicely to do something.
#23 Work with the provinces of Saskatchewan and Manitoba, Yukon Territory and the Northwest Territories, and the States of Alaska and Montana, and all associated First Nations as partners, to secure one or more Transportation Utility Corridors (TUCs) to the Hudson Bay, the Mackenzie Delta region, and/or Alaska.This expands a previous bill so that we work with more jurisdictions than just Manitoba and Saskatchewan. It seems fine, but it is part of a “get a pipeline to somewhere” bill, so not ideal.
#24 Divide the roles and responsibilities of the Minister of Justice position into separate ministries of Attorney General and Solicitor General.I'm worried this is an attempt to hamstring both proposed ministries (though it's likely just an attempt to expand the number of cabinet ministers), but nothing obvious is coming up. It does mean that the people who prosecute cops won't be the people in charge of the cops, so that's ok in a platonically ideal sense where a conservative government would actually prosecute cops.
#26 Support fair, efficient, open, and competitive consumer and industrial electricity market and conduct a review to determine market competitiveness and whether there is excess market concentration resulting in high electricity prices and if so, determine methods to correct the excess market concentration.Half-measure. They should go farther and drag them back to being a government utility. I'd rather my utility bill was smaller and went towards making the grid better rather than a millionaire's yacht collection larger.
#27 Repeal the no fault Insurance (also known as Direct Compensation for Property Damage) legislation in Alberta and return to torte-based (also known as at-fault based) insurance.I guess.
#30 Ensure that social assistance support programs such as Assured Income for the Severely Handicapped (AISH), seniors’ benefits, and the Alberta Child and Family Benefit continue to be indexed to inflation.This is a good idea, but they should make the current amounts livable first. Having a not-good-enough value indexed to inflation means it will never be good enough. Also, note that this is the last proposal, so it's the least likely to be gotten to.