Entry tags:
Pay Phones
Calgary is removing all of its pay phones. There's less than 20 left in the city, and they'll likely be gone by the end of the year. Killed off by ubiquitous cell phones.
Now the main reason why Telus wants to get rid of them is because of the cost. A payphone is expensive to buy/maintain/keep connected. They are tough beasts, but no one is making the parts anymore, which means areas that want to keep them have to order expensive custom-made parts, or cannibalize other phones.
I think we should keep them. Or rather, I think we should replace their functionality. Hear me out.
Why is a pay phone expensive? Well, they need to built like tanks so people don't bust into them for loose change. They need to have power and connectivity to the phone network. They need to be fixed. So how do you get around that?
One solution came from a talk I went to a few years by a city traffic engineer. He said that putting new lighted intersections in was a factor of magnitude cheaper now than it was twenty years ago. Then, you needed to dig up the street so the lights had power and could talk to each other (you don't want contrasting traffic lights both going green at the same time). Now you could do all of that with wifi/solar/batteries. An intersection that took a million dollars to build now took less than $100,000.
Next, don't charge for the phone call. A lot of why pay phones need to be tanks is to keep people from stealing them. Telus should simply provide this as a service (we'd need to legislate this - there's no way they'll do it on their own).
So what would these new payphones look like? You'd have the post in the ground/side of the building. It would contain a rechargeable battery and a solar panel. There would be a radio inside that talks to the cellular network (and provide the phone number). Now you don't have to worry about digging up the street.
Attached to it would be a heavy duty phone. Metal case, tough buttons, Metal cable and handset. And that's it. It would have a simple connection behind it that connects to the radio/power. It would bolt on so that all of the connections were hidden. And if it broke, a technician would simply unbolt it and replace it. The individual units would be repaired off site.
Where would you put them? In Calgary I'd suggest one at every C-Train station, plus every civic building or Telus facility. Give malls an option to set one up if they'd like.
Anyway, those are my thoughts. I think it would still be useful, but I acknowledge it will never make a profit. That's why it's a public service, which isn't a dirty word.
Now the main reason why Telus wants to get rid of them is because of the cost. A payphone is expensive to buy/maintain/keep connected. They are tough beasts, but no one is making the parts anymore, which means areas that want to keep them have to order expensive custom-made parts, or cannibalize other phones.
I think we should keep them. Or rather, I think we should replace their functionality. Hear me out.
Why is a pay phone expensive? Well, they need to built like tanks so people don't bust into them for loose change. They need to have power and connectivity to the phone network. They need to be fixed. So how do you get around that?
One solution came from a talk I went to a few years by a city traffic engineer. He said that putting new lighted intersections in was a factor of magnitude cheaper now than it was twenty years ago. Then, you needed to dig up the street so the lights had power and could talk to each other (you don't want contrasting traffic lights both going green at the same time). Now you could do all of that with wifi/solar/batteries. An intersection that took a million dollars to build now took less than $100,000.
Next, don't charge for the phone call. A lot of why pay phones need to be tanks is to keep people from stealing them. Telus should simply provide this as a service (we'd need to legislate this - there's no way they'll do it on their own).
So what would these new payphones look like? You'd have the post in the ground/side of the building. It would contain a rechargeable battery and a solar panel. There would be a radio inside that talks to the cellular network (and provide the phone number). Now you don't have to worry about digging up the street.
Attached to it would be a heavy duty phone. Metal case, tough buttons, Metal cable and handset. And that's it. It would have a simple connection behind it that connects to the radio/power. It would bolt on so that all of the connections were hidden. And if it broke, a technician would simply unbolt it and replace it. The individual units would be repaired off site.
Where would you put them? In Calgary I'd suggest one at every C-Train station, plus every civic building or Telus facility. Give malls an option to set one up if they'd like.
Anyway, those are my thoughts. I think it would still be useful, but I acknowledge it will never make a profit. That's why it's a public service, which isn't a dirty word.